My Immortal

StartSomething · Subject: My Immortal Mon Apr 07, 2008 11:36 am

This is the song everyone loves!! Wink

Even people that don't even like evanescence like this song.

I personally prefer the piano only version as its so beautiful.....

views on this song??

_________________
"I can't remember the time or place.
Or what you were wearing.
Its unclear about how we met.
All I know - it was the best conversation that I've ever had."

**Caz** · Subject: Re: My Immortal Mon Apr 07, 2008 11:39 am

I do like this song a lot, but i tend to skip it a lot too Razz

I think you need to be in the mood for this one as it can be very depressing. But it still gives me goose pimples and nearly brings me to tears Twisted Evil

This song definitely does have the WOW factor for me, even after all this time

_________________
Femme Metal Store
Femme Metal WebZine
Femme Metal Forum

**Deadly Poison** · Subject: Re: My Immortal Tue Apr 08, 2008 4:47 pm

My least favorite, I love the video but I don't like the song that much Razz

_________________

Dania · Subject: Re: My Immortal Wed Apr 09, 2008 6:45 pm

I Tend To Skip It 2!! I Prefer The Band Version Than The All Piano Version! But It's My Least FaV Song On Fallen!

_________________
Drown my will to fly

StartSomething · Subject: Re: My Immortal Thu Apr 10, 2008 11:59 am

I think My Immortal is for music fans that don't really like Evanescence as most Ev fans don't think its that great Twisted Evil

I think its a song that will last forever.....theres a music channel on tv, can't remember what its called now, but it basically just plays cheesy rock ballads all day like Meatloaf, Ronan Keating, Bryan Adams that sort of thing and they always play My Immortal as well lol!

_________________
"I can't remember the time or place.
Or what you were wearing.
Its unclear about how we met.
All I know - it was the best conversation that I've ever had."

blackbutterfly · Subject: My Immortal Sun May 04, 2008 7:41 pm

My Immortal is one the best songs which has been made ever Very Happy

Every Ev fan have heard that song !
I just loove that song I love you

LucidLove · Subject: Re: My Immortal Mon May 05, 2008 6:40 pm

One of my favorite songs of all time... I love both versions of the song, with the band or just with the piano. I love you

However, I have a friend who always plays a terrible version of the song on the piano whenever she can, so the song can get quite annoying to me at times. -__-
Razz

_________________
You can't escape...

you don't want to escape.

StartSomething · Subject: Re: My Immortal Mon May 05, 2008 7:56 pm

LucidLove wrote:

One of my favorite songs of all time... I love both versions of the song, with the band or just with the piano. I love you

However, I have a friend who always plays a terrible version of the song on the piano whenever she can, so the song can get quite annoying to me at times. -__-
Razz

Tell your friend to stop killing a great song Kelly! Laughing

_________________
"I can't remember the time or place.
Or what you were wearing.
Its unclear about how we met.
All I know - it was the best conversation that I've ever had."

Dania · Subject: Re: My Immortal Wed May 07, 2008 7:43 pm

I HaVe To Admit That My Immortal Is The Only Song People Know Around Here (Well And BMTL But Not Much As MI)! And Most Of Them Don't Know EVanescence They Just Know My Immortal!

_________________
Drown my will to fly

blackbutterfly · Subject: Re: My Immortal Thu May 08, 2008 3:16 pm

Teardrop101 wrote:

I HaVe To Admit That My Immortal Is The Only Song People Know Around Here (Well And BMTL But Not Much As MI)! And Most Of Them Don't Know EVanescence They Just Know My Immortal!

Yeah, my friend that I've already talked a bit about,
have only heard that two songs. When I say I realy like other songs like
Everybody's fool, like you, Turniquiet and so on.. she's just a big questionmark Razz

Dania · Subject: Re: My Immortal Sat May 10, 2008 5:15 pm

Quote:

Yeah, my friend that I've already talked a bit about,
have only heard that two songs. When I say I realy like other songs like
Everybody's fool, like you, Turniquiet and so on.. she's just a big questionmark

When I Say EVanescence They Say What?! But When I Say BMTL Or MI They Say Yeah I LoVe These Songs But Other Than That Nothing!!

_________________
Drown my will to fly

blackbutterfly · Subject: Re: My Immortal Sun May 11, 2008 11:00 am

Teardrop101 wrote:

Quote:

Yeah, my friend that I've already talked a bit about,
have only heard that two songs. When I say I realy like other songs like
Everybody's fool, like you, Turniquiet and so on.. she's just a big questionmark

When I Say EVanescence They Say What?! But When I Say BMTL Or MI They Say Yeah I LoVe These Songs But Other Than That Nothing!!

Yeah, that's quiet anoying Razz

StartSomething · Subject: Re: My Immortal Sat May 17, 2008 12:59 pm

Its strange that people who like My Immortal don't always check out the albums! They'll probably like them Very Happy

_________________
"I can't remember the time or place.
Or what you were wearing.
Its unclear about how we met.
All I know - it was the best conversation that I've ever had."

Britrogue · Subject: Re: My Immortal Thu May 22, 2008 2:47 pm

I know EVERYONE loves this song, but it is rather awesome. My favourite version is the Band/Guitars down version.

_________________

The Last Song...

Dania · Subject: Re: My Immortal Sat May 24, 2008 8:02 pm

Quote:

My favourite version is the Band/Guitars down version

.

Mine 2!! Smile

_________________
Drown my will to fly

Like U · Subject: Re: My Immortal Sat Aug 23, 2008 9:14 pm

I LOVE THIS SONG LOVE I TELL U LOVE

_________________

El Poderin de Amy Lee!!!

KalliopePhoenix · Subject: Re: My Immortal Wed Sep 03, 2008 3:32 am

This is a really good song...but you definitely have to be in the right mood for it. It was actually the first song I heard from Evanescence, rather than Bring Me To Life like most other people. I just didn't know it was them at the time...

It's a great song, and both versions have their assets, but I tend to prefer the one with the rest of the band, all the guitars and stuff. That depresses me less. Smile

And just because it is, for me, the oldest song because it was my first, I tend to skip it. Since there are even better songs.

Dania · Subject: Re: My Immortal Wed Sep 03, 2008 7:56 pm

Quote:

This is a really good song...but you definitely have to be in the right mood for it. It was actually the first song I heard from Evanescence, rather than Bring Me To Life like most other people. I just didn't know it was them at the time...

It's a great song, and both versions have their assets, but I tend to prefer the one with the rest of the band, all the guitars and stuff. That depresses me less. Smile

And just because it is, for me, the oldest song because it was my first, I tend to skip it. Since there are even better songs.

Yeah I Agree With All Of It Razz

_________________
Drown my will to fly

EvanescenceGirl · Subject: Re: My Immortal Wed Sep 03, 2008 8:30 pm

Best version is the band version, IMO.
Not one of my favorite songs. Too calm I guess lol
The lyrics are good.

_________________

Dania · Subject: Re: My Immortal Wed Sep 03, 2008 8:40 pm

Yeah I Know It's Too Clam For Me Too! Razz

The Lyrics Rocks!

Quote:

you used to captivate me
by your resonating light
but now i'm bound by the life you left behind
your face it haunts my once pleasant dreams
your voice it chased away all the sanity in me

_________________
Drown my will to fly